Debunking the Goal Setting Theory - 3802 Words

Debunking the Goal Setting Theory Presented to Trudy Dunson, Instructor MGMT 2125, Performance Management By Andrea Smith 10/13/2014 Often times in the business world, organizations become so fixated on the goals they set, that when they begin to go wrong, an organization will invest more into that goal instead of looking for a different path. Oliver Burkeman’s book, â€Å"The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking† devotes a whole chapter to the importance or lack thereof of setting goals. In his book, he tells a story of Chris Kayes who was on the foothills of Mt. Everest at the same time the tragedy that took the lives of eight climbers depicted in the book, â€Å"In Thin Air.† Kayes observed even through this†¦show more content†¦However on the flip side these same traits used to create a positive environment can also be used to against the organization. We start with the letter â€Å"S† for specific as this commands that the goal to be focused and attentive. Unfortunately though, this can actually cause a too narrowed focus where employees will overlook important details of the task. With a narrowed focus, employees become blind to everything else but their task and the often times miss a critical detail that could potentially steer them into a new direction and a more profitable gain or prevent a fatal error from occurring. An example in this can be seen in the automotive industry of late and the entire vehicle recalls that have been made due to faulty engine or ignition parts that have caused human fatalities. The automotive industry giants have a specific goal to create a top of the line vehicle fast and get it out to the market that they continuously pass over safety issues and inspections in order to accomplish this single goal. In keeping with the classic notion that you get what you reward (Kerr, 1975, 1995), goal setting may cause the employee to miss important aspects of their task or performance that are not specifically outlined by the goal setting system. Next we move on to the â€Å"M† for measurable and the hazards that can arise from putting a measurable capacity on goals. Being able to measure progress is said to keep the employees on track and provideShow MoreRelatedComparison Of RawlsTheory Of Justice1724 Words   |  7 Pages Rawls’ Theory of Justice and Neoclassical theory are similar, but not fundamentally compatible. While Rawls does spend a lot of time focusing on specialization and private ownership, both of which Adam Smith and the neoclassical school strongly endorse. However, there are certain contradictions between the Rawls’ Theory of Justice and neoclassical thought that Bradford brings up in his paper â€Å"The Economics of Rawlsian Justice: Can it be Neoclassical?†. These contradictions are mainly the disparitiesRead MoreThe Rights Of The State1727 Words   |  7 Pagesto promote the rule of law have addressed a variety of state and social institutions. To illustrate concretely the way law reform programs differ depending upon the ends they serve, In discussing each of the goals cited above, it is just to highlight how actors seeking to advance such goals approach the reform of the judiciary. Analyzing the diverse rationales also helps refine and tamper the conception of â€Å"Appropriate giving of Directives movement† by pointing out the different interests and diverseRead MoreLiterature Review - Managerial Skills2326 Words   |  10 PagesMintzberg’s analysis of the relationship between a supervisor and subordinate as being mostly hierarchical. He also refers to Mintzberg’s theory of management as professional gibberish. The theory states that managing takes place on three planes, from the conceptual to the concrete: with information, through people, and to action, directly. The research paper Debunking management skills and competencies myths  although anonymously written provides insight into the myth that management skills and competenciesRead MoreCritically Evaluate the Role of Leaders and Managers Contributes to Employee Motivation and Engagement Within Organisations2115 Words   |  9 Pagesknowledge, skills, tools, and experiences therefore employees will to follow them. For organization, to gain and sustain employees can not only create value and high levels of performance, but also as the only vehicle through which an organizational goals are accomplished. More importantly, the best style of leaderships is more than one style; it depends on followers’ needs. As we know that management engages in the process of integrating work activities therefore people can complete work more efficientRead MoreEssay on Summary of Ornstein6963 Words   |  28 PagesFoundations of Curriculum Chapter 3. Historical Foundations of Curriculum Chapter 4. Psychological Foundations of Curriculum Chapter 5. Social Foundations of Curriculum Chapter 6. Curriculum Theory Part II. Principles of Curriculum Chapter 7. Curriculum Development Chapter 8. Curriculum Design Chapter 9. Aims, Goals, and Objectives Chapter 10. Curriculum Implementation Chapter 11. Curriculum Evaluation Part III. Issues of Curriculum Chapter 12. Curriculum Issues and Trends Chapter 13. FutureRead MoreEthical Leadership Is Mostly About Leadership Integrity2938 Words   |  12 Pagesmoral example for their followers. The ethical actions and behaviour of top management have to be consistent with their teaching, otherwise formal ethical training and codes are bound to have a slim chance of success. The outcome of organisational goals is dependent on the leader’s capabilities to set the direction for employee behaviour, which includes promotion, strategies and appraisal (Brown Mitchell 2010). This essay will examine how leadership integrity plays a part in building an ethicalRead MoreHow Ethical Leadership is Associated with Employee Output and Organizational Culture1957 Words   |  8 Pagesdirect and immediate communication with the managers inside the organization. After employees with direct communication are identified by the organization a short briefing sessions will be organized with both managers and employees to explain the goals of the study. Both groups will be informed of the study with equal information, time, and use of words in the morning. After gaining their consent to participate in the study, each member will have a survey distributed to their work emails to beRead MoreNegotiation Class2300 Words   |  10 Pagesthe time that’s why we always need to negotiate salary, position†¦ Origin of the world Salary: salt ------------------------------------------------- The traps of negotiation: 1. Leaving money on the table (lose-lose negotiation) 2. Setting for too little: faire trop de concessions, se contenter de trop peu 3. Walking away from the table 4. Settling for terms worse than your alternative (the agreement bias) cà ©der pour des conditions moins bonnes que son alternative ------------------------------------------------- Read MoreEmployee Engagement4674 Words   |  19 Pagesgoods. Approximately 70% of the Company s sales in the XYZ are through traditional privately owned and independent small retail stores distributed nationwide. Appendix A presents the organizational structure of XYZ sales business unit. The goals of the sales business unit are: 1. Grow sales volume 2. Attract, develop and retain the best talent 3. Maintain good relations with the trade market 1.2 What is Employee Engagement? Whilst the current lack of empirical research on employee engagementRead MoreConcept Analysis on Stress Among Nurses Essay5023 Words   |  21 Pagesvision of the unity of knowledge. The article begins by examining the notion of paradigms and worldviews as currently used in the nursing literature and suggests that the concept of a single paradigm supports a philosophy inconsistent with nursing’s goal of building knowledge on the nature of the human response. Next, the strength of plurality in nursing knowledge development, its warrantable evidence, and the concept of a unity of knowledge to support knowledge development and practice is articulated